Why Prospect Heights Collectors Choose Evanston Coins for Selling Rare and High-End Coin Collections

Evanston Coins is the trusted choice for Prospect Heights residents who want to sell rare coins, inherited collections, or complete numismatic estates. Our team has decades of experience in U.S. and world coinage, giving us the expertise to identify and value coins accurately — from early American rarities to modern bullion. We proudly serve Prospect Heights and the surrounding northwest suburbs with fair, transparent offers and same-day payment.

Whether you’re liquidating a lifetime collection, handling an estate, or simply curious about what your coins are worth, Evanston Coins provides a professional, secure, and rewarding experience for every seller.

We Buy Entire Coin Collections, Large or Small

At Evanston Coins, we regularly purchase full coin collections and valuable single coins from Prospect Heights residents, including:

• U.S. gold and silver coins: Liberty Head, Indian Head, and Saint-Gaudens gold coins, plus Morgan and Peace dollars
• Early American coinage: large cents, half cents, three-cent pieces, nickels, and early copper
• Certified coins: PCGS, NGC, and ANACS-graded rarities
• Bullion coins and bars: American Eagles, Maple Leafs, Krugerrands, Philharmonics, and others
• World and ancient coins: gold sovereigns, thalers, ducats, Roman and Greek coins
• Proof and mint sets, albums, and complete estate collections

We specialize in evaluating entire holdings and can appraise your collection on-site or by appointment. Every coin is carefully reviewed for rarity, grade, and current market demand to ensure you receive top value.

Expert Appraisals and Immediate Payment

Our evaluations are handled by professional numismatists with a deep understanding of collector and dealer markets. We take the time to explain our appraisal process clearly, so you’ll know exactly how each offer is determined. Once a price is agreed upon, payment is made on the spot — no mailing delays or consignment waiting periods.

Safe, Private, and Professional Transactions

Selling your coin collection should feel comfortable and secure. Evanston Coins provides a private appraisal environment with 24-hour surveillance, dual-buzzer entry, and discreet one-on-one evaluations. For larger collections, we also offer private appointments and secure estate consultations.

Free Coin Appraisals for Prospect Heights Residents

Not sure what your coins are worth? Evanston Coins offers free, no-obligation appraisals to all Prospect Heights clients. Whether you’ve inherited a collection, are downsizing, or just want to understand current market value, we’ll provide a transparent evaluation backed by the latest PCGS, NGC, and Greysheet pricing data.

Your Trusted North-Shore Coin Buyer

Evanston Coins has earned its reputation as one of the most knowledgeable and reliable coin dealers in the Chicago area. We’re proud to offer honest service, accurate appraisals, and top-dollar payouts for collections large and small. Prospect Heights residents choose us for our expertise, integrity, and professionalism — the hallmarks of every transaction at Evanston Coins.